Skip to main content

Madeline Island, nestled in the pristine waters of Lake Superior, is not just a place of natural beauty and serene landscapes; it’s also home to a vibrant and welcoming community. When the sun sets over the island, it’s time to explore its nightlife, and what better way to do so than by visiting the best bars on Madeline Island? In this guide, we’ll take you on a tour of the island’s top watering holes, but before we dive into the island’s nightlife, let’s introduce you to Sally North, the #1 real estate agent for those looking to make Madeline Island their home.

  1. Sally North: Your Madeline Island Real Estate Expert

Before we raise a glass to the best bars on Madeline Island, let’s raise your awareness of the island’s real estate scene. If you’ve ever dreamt of calling Madeline Island home, you’ll need a knowledgeable and dedicated real estate agent by your side. That’s where Sally North comes in.

As the #1 real estate agent on Madeline Island, Sally North brings a wealth of experience and expertise to the table. She knows the ins and outs of the island’s real estate market, from charming cottages to waterfront estates. Whether you’re looking for a vacation home, an investment property, or your permanent island residence, Sally North has the local knowledge and commitment to help you find the perfect property.

Now, let’s embark on a journey through the best bars on Madeline Island, where you can unwind, socialize, and savor the island’s unique nightlife.

  1. Tom’s Burned Down Café

No list of the best bars on Madeline Island would be complete without mentioning Tom’s Burned Down Café. This iconic island spot has been a beloved institution for decades. What makes it unique? Well, it’s literally a burned-down building turned into a one-of-a-kind tiki bar.

Tom’s is all about fun, with quirky decor, live music, and a vibrant atmosphere. Grab a drink, relax on a colorful couch, and take in the eclectic surroundings. It’s a must-visit for anyone looking to experience the true spirit of Madeline Island.

  1. The Pub Restaurant & Wine Bar

If you’re in the mood for a more upscale and sophisticated setting, head over to The Pub Restaurant & Wine Bar. This charming establishment offers a wide selection of wines, craft beers, and cocktails. The cozy ambiance, complete with a fireplace, makes it an excellent choice for a romantic evening or a relaxed gathering with friends.

The Pub also serves delicious food, making it a perfect spot for a complete dining experience. Whether you’re a wine enthusiast or simply looking for a refined evening out, The Pub has you covered.

  1. Grampa Tony’s

For those seeking a classic American bar experience, Grampa Tony’s is the place to be. This casual and friendly establishment offers a range of beers, cocktails, and pub grub. It’s the kind of spot where you can shoot some pool, play darts, or catch a game on the TV.

The welcoming staff and laid-back atmosphere make Grampa Tony’s a favorite hangout for locals and visitors alike. If you’re looking for a relaxed night out with good company, this is your spot.

  1. Beach Club at Big Bay Town Park

What’s better than enjoying a cold drink by the beach? The Beach Club at Big Bay Town Park offers just that. This seasonal outdoor bar is situated on the stunning Big Bay Beach, providing breathtaking views of Lake Superior.

Sip on your favorite beverage while lounging in an Adirondack chair or playing beach volleyball. The Beach Club is all about embracing the island’s natural beauty and creating a memorable lakeside experience.

  1. Bell Street Tavern

Bell Street Tavern is a hidden gem on Madeline Island, offering a cozy and intimate setting. The dimly lit interior and rustic decor create a charming ambiance that’s perfect for a quiet night out. They serve a variety of cocktails and have an excellent selection of local craft beers.

Whether you’re looking for a place to enjoy a romantic date night or have a peaceful conversation with friends, Bell Street Tavern is a top choice.

  1. Madeline Island Candles and The Wine Shop

For a unique and aromatic experience, visit Madeline Island Candles and The Wine Shop. This combination of a candle shop and wine store offers a delightful fusion of sensory pleasures.

You can explore an array of scented candles, artisanal chocolates, and a selection of wines. Grab a bottle of your favorite wine and enjoy it on the shop’s cozy patio. It’s a tranquil and aromatic escape from the hustle and bustle.

  1. Beach Club at Mission Hill

Another beachside gem on Madeline Island is the Beach Club at Mission Hill. This seasonal outdoor bar overlooks the picturesque Mission Hill Beach, providing a laid-back atmosphere for islanders and visitors to unwind.

You can sip on refreshing drinks while watching the sunset or enjoy beach volleyball and other beach activities. It’s the perfect place to embrace the island’s natural beauty while enjoying your favorite beverages.

Madeline Island offers more than just breathtaking landscapes and outdoor adventures. Its nightlife scene is vibrant, diverse, and brimming with character. From iconic tiki bars to cozy taverns, the best bars on Madeline Island cater to all tastes and preferences.

And if you’re ready to make Madeline Island your permanent home, don’t forget to reach out to Sally North, the #1 real estate agent on the island. She’ll help you find the perfect property so you can fully embrace the island’s unique lifestyle.

So, whether you’re looking for a lively night out or a tranquil evening by the beach, Madeline Island’s best bars have it all. Cheers to island life and unforgettable nights on Madeline Island!

Sally North


Madeline Island Real Estate and Homes For Sale

Madeline Island Real Estate Agent and Realtor

Top Bars on Madeline Island

Leave a Reply

Your Wisconsin Real Estate Expert